Old Mill Tasty Shop Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Old Mill Tasty Shop, a charming gem located in the heart of Wichita, KS. This delightful diner offers a nostalgic escape with its classic Mexican-inspired sandwiches and comforting dishes. The atmosphere is a heartwarming throwback to mid-20th century America, featuring cozy booths and a vintage soda fountain that beckons you to indulge.
Old Mill Tasty Shop prides itself on a menu that includes generous portions of hearty comfort food. Must-tries include the chicken salad sandwich with homemade blue cheese dressing and the rich tomato bisque, perfect for vegetarians. Don’t miss the famous malts and house-made sodas that bring feelings of childhood nostalgia. The service is friendly and attentive, adding to the inviting ambiance where patrons feel right at home.
Whether you're seeking a hearty lunch with friends or a sweet treat after dinner, Old Mill Tasty Shop fits the bill perfectly. With options for takeout and delivery, why not bring this slice of comfort to your dining table?
Sandwiches
Hot Ham Cheese
With choice of mayo or mustard on kaiser roll
Sliced Bbq Beef Brisket
On your choice of rye, wheat or kaiser roll
Muffaleta
Turkey pastrami, turkey, swiss jack cheese, topped with olive salad and heated on kaiser roll
Vegetarian Muffaleta
Mushrooms, tomatoes, red onions, swiss jack cheese, topped with olive salad and heated on kaiser roll
Reuben
Corned beef, sauerkraut special mustard sauce on toasted wheat, marble rye or our vegetarian option
Vegetarian Reuben
Mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, sauerkraut, spinach, swiss cheese special mustard sauce heated on marble rye or wheat bread
Pita Bread Stuffed With Hummus
Red onion slices, alfalfa sprouts, carrots, salsa, monterey jack cheese and tomatoes
Hot Turkey Pastrami
Monterey jack cheese on toasted marble rye with dijon mustard
Peanut Butter, Banana Honey
Or peanut butter jelly on white bread
Liverwurst
Lettuce, mayo, red onion on white bread
Club Sandwich
Ham, turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo on white toast
Toasted Chicken Salad Club Sandwich
Chicken salad, with bacon, lettuce, and tomato on white toast
Toasted Classic Blt
Bacon, lettuce, tomato with mayo on white toast
Tuna Melt
Homemade tuna salad on white bread with jack cheese melted on top. Served face open
Kc Steak Soup
Served with whole wheat rolls
Tomato Bisque
Served with whole wheat rolls
Green Chili
Topped with cheese and served with tortilla
Soups
Mexican Dishes
Chips Salsa
Vegetarian Burrito
Whole beans, mushrooms and tomatoes topped with salsa, cheese, sour cream and sprouts gluten free without tortilla
Fiesta Salad
Fresh greens with tomatoes, cheese, green chilis, pinto beans, salsa, tortilla chip crumbles and sour cream
Cheese Crisps
Tortilla baked crisp with melted cheese, green onion, green chilies, topped with sour cream and salsa
Chicken, Sour Cream Nachos
Chips topped with melted cheese, chicken chunks, sour cream, salsa jalapeno slices
House Salad
Crisp greens, carrots, cucumber and sprouts with two cheeses
Spinach Salad
With chicken salad, crab salad or tuna salad
Chef Salad
Fresh greens, ham, turkey, tomatoes, cheese, egg and bacon
Blue Plate Special
Changes daily please check menu board
Salads
Beverages
Milk
Chocolate Milk
Coffee Or Tea
Orange Juice
Ham
Sausage
Bacon
1 Egg
2 Eggs
Potatoes
Toast
Biscuit
Blueberry Muffin
English Muffins
Tortilla
Sour Cream
Side Of Salsa
Side Of Gravy
Side Of Green Chili
Side Orders
Drinks
Fresh Ground Coffee
Milk
1 Dip
In a dish
2 Dips
In a dish
12 Sundae
Aspen Snowball
1 dip vanilla, hot fudge, coconut
Malts And Shakes
Choice of flavors, made the oldfashioned way, includes one ingredient
Ice Cream Soda
Choice of flavors
Banana Split
Vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice cream with banana, chocolate, pineapple strawberry toppings, nuts, whipped cream, cherries
Floats
2 dips of vanilla, choice of soda pop
Turtle
2 dips of vanilla, butterscotch hot fudge topping. pecan halves, whipped cream and cherries
12 Turtle
Very Cherry Sundae
One dip of vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, maraschino cherries, and bananas and whipped cream
Old Mill Special
Vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice cream marshmallow, chocolate, strawberry topping. whipped cream and cherries
Hot Fudge Brownie Delite
Brownie topped with ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, pecans and a cherry
Cones
Ice Cream Specialties
Homemade Desserts
Homemade Carrot Cake
With cream cheese icing and pecans
Apple Bread Pudding
With homemade caramel and whipped cream
Homemade Brownie
Huevos Rancheros
Corn tortillas with beans, cheese, red or green chili, topped with two eggs
Sausage Green Chili Omelette
Made with fresh new mexico green chilies and sausage topped with hollandaise
Breakfast Burro
Eggs, cheese, and chilies in a flour tortilla, topped with red or green chili, and cheese
Spinach Omelette
Spinach, onion and mushrooms with cream cheese topped with hollandaise
Sunnyside Chilies
Chopped new mexico green chilies topped with monterrey jack cheese, basted with two eggs
Desert Omelette
Egg omelette stuffed with artichoke hearts, sprouts, tomatoes, and mushrooms topped with hollandaise
Eggs Benedict
Muffins, ham, poached eggs topped with hollandaise
Bacon Cheddar Omelette
Topped with hollandaise
Sausage, Ham Or Bacon
Ham Cheese Omelette
French Toast
Half Order
Biscuits Gravy
Pancakes
Regular or blueberry